Start with Memphis if the goal is to find a lower-cost rental with more room to absorb expenses. Its Zillow home-value index is $146,746 versus $376,648 in Knoxville, while the gross-yield screen is 10.46% versus 5.53%. Memphis therefore warrants the first cash-flow test, but the spread does not tell you how much rent you will collect or what you will keep after expenses.
Start with Knoxville for a first review of citywide population and employment indicators. Its population rose 4.84% between overlapping ACS vintages, while Memphis's fell 5.05%. Both figures compare the full spans of the ACS vintages. Knoxville also has lower surveyed unemployment (4.54% versus 8.31%) and lower overall housing vacancy (10.55% versus 12.68%). Those citywide signals give Knoxville a stronger starting point for local demand research. Validate lease-up and the purchase premium with comparable properties.
Use the same property type, condition, financing structure, management assumptions and reserve policy in both cities. Then use nearby lease comps to set achievable rent and local quotes to price operating costs and repairs. Test a slower lease-up and a larger repair reserve in each city. See whether Memphis retains its cash-flow advantage and whether Knoxville has enough evidence of steadier occupancy to justify committing more capital. Don't use the citywide rent index as a rent target without checking concessions, time on market and the incomes of households likely to rent the property.

