Counties / Ohio / Carroll County

Carroll County, OH

FIPS 39019 · population 26,659 · part of Canton, OH

$209k
Zillow home value · 2026-06
The numbers

What this county costs and earns

Everything here joins on the county FIPS code, so each figure comes from the agency that publishes it with no name matching in between.

Zillow home value
$209k
▲ 8.2% year over year
Zillow ZHVI · direct
ACS median gross rent
$863
occupied-unit survey; not current asking rent
Census ACS · surveyed
Gross yield
n/a
gross yield cannot be computed without measured market rent
requires both measured price and measured rent
HUD 2-bed standard
$1,086
the Section 8 payment standard
HUD Fair Market Rent · direct
Independent price check

Do two methods point the same way?

Zillow estimates a current home value. FHFA tracks repeat mortgage transactions. Their growth rates should be read side by side, not averaged.

Both annual signals move in the same direction
FHFA five-year cumulative+55.9%not annualized · through 2025
0%ZILLOW ZHVI2026-06+8.2%FHFA HPI2025+5.3%
Annual changes use different methods and may use different periods. The comparison checks direction and magnitude; it does not create a blended estimate. Zillow county ZHVI pulled 2026-07-26; FHFA annual county HPI pulled 2026-07-28.
Owner-reported value$183k
Surveyed gross rent$863
Rent burden 30%+37.1%
Median year built1974
Housing composition

Who occupies the stock—and what it is

ACS 2024 5-year
16.3%vacant
13,390estimated housing units
Occupied tenure21.3% renter
owner 78.7%renter 21.3%
Structure mix79.9% single-family
Single-family 79.9%20+ units 0.2%Mobile home 12.9%Other 6.9%
ACS estimates describe the standing housing stock and occupied tenure. They do not measure current listings, transaction prices or asking rents.

Survey source: Census ACS 5-year — county housing value, tenure and stock · ACS 2024 5-year · pulled 2026-07-30. These values describe different housing universes and are not combined into gross yield.

Annual average covered jobs6,118▲ 0.4% from the prior annual release
Covered establishments556annual average reporting locations
Average weekly wage$989▲ 5.9% from the prior annual release
Largest private supersectorTrade, transportation, and utilities25.7% of disclosed private covered jobs
Local labor base

Jobs, pay and private-sector concentration

2025
0%COVERED JOBS+0.4%WEEKLY WAGE+5.9%Trade, transportation, and utilities25.7%
Annual QCEW counts cover jobs located at reporting establishments. The industry share uses disclosed private covered employment; it is not a resident-employment measure or a forecast.

Workplace source: BLS QCEW — county employment and wages · annual county employment and wages 2025 vs 2024 · pulled 2026-07-31. QCEW counts covered jobs located in the county, not employed residents or the metro score’s CES/LAUS series.

County brief

What the local evidence says

01Decision frame

Carroll County’s decision tension is a rising county valuation signal without published market rent to test income against acquisition cost. At Zillow’s 2026-06 county observation, median home value was $208,821, up 8.19%; FHFA’s annual 2025 repeat-transaction HPI rose 5.35%. The measures point in the same direction, but have distinct vintages and methods and must not be combined into one appreciation rate. Investors needing cash-flow evidence should investigate; gross yield cannot be computed.

02Housing economics

Carrying-cost review is more actionable than rent underwriting here. The effective property-tax rate is 0.94%, with median annual tax of $1,725. HUD’s two-bedroom FMR is $1,086 per month, but it is a payment standard rather than market asking rent and cannot support a rent or yield calculation. Supplied Realtor.com MLS evidence shows lower median listing prices and more active listings. Those are seller asking-price and visible-supply measures, not closed-sale values or proof of buyer demand.

03Demand & competition

County QCEW annual data show covered jobs located at county workplaces grew 0.41%, while the average covered-worker weekly wage was $989. Trade, transportation, and utilities is the largest disclosed private supersector, not a measure of the whole economy. Migration recorded a net loss of 56 tax-return households, although inbound movers’ average AGI exceeded outbound movers’ by $163. The investor measure records 12 of 234 purchase mortgages, or 5.13%, as non-occupant activity; this is a measured buyer segment, not a full account of competition.

04Risk & next checks

Inland flood is the dominant hazard, and modeled climate loss equals 0.10% of building value per year; it is not a parcel-specific insurance quote or realized damage estimate. Next checks should obtain market rent, vacancy, lease terms, operating costs, insurance and flood-zone information, property condition, and closed-sale comparables. Their absence prevents gross-yield, net-cash-flow, parcel-risk, and acquisition-price conclusions from county-level evidence alone.

Cities & communities

Where people live within Carroll County

Census-recognized incorporated places and CDPs that intersect this county. The list does not pretend to include every neighborhood or informal community.

Population scale

Largest Census places

ACS 2024 5-year
Minerva village*3.2KCarrollton village2.8KMalvern village1.5KLake Mohawk CDP1.4KMagnolia village*1.1KPekin CDP369Sherrodsville village353Dellroy village236
Bars use total place population, not a county-share estimate. An asterisk marks a place that crosses a county line.
Official directory

9 Census places

Population
  1. 01
    Minerva villageIncorporated place · spans 3 counties
    3,196
  2. 02
    Carrollton villageIncorporated place
    2,810
  3. 03
    Malvern villageIncorporated place
    1,502
  4. 04
    Lake Mohawk CDPCensus-designated place
    1,409
  5. 05
    Magnolia villageIncorporated place · spans 2 counties
    1,061
  6. 06
    Pekin CDPCensus-designated place
    369
  7. 07
    Sherrodsville villageIncorporated place
    353
  8. 08
    Dellroy villageIncorporated place
    236
  9. 09
    Leesville villageIncorporated place
    221

Population is the total place-wide ACS estimate, not an allocated county share. A place crossing a county line is labelled explicitly. Source: Census ACS 5-year — cities and communities · ACS 2024 5-year · pulled 2026-07-30.

Risk, demand and competition

The three things a price does not tell you

01
Risk & carrying costFEMA NRI + Census ACS
Dominant hazardinland flooding

0.101% of building value expected lost per year

Effective property tax0.94%

$1,725 median annual bill

02
DemandIRS SOI household flows
Net migration-56

653 in · 709 out

Arriving vs leaving income+$163

$54,911 arriving · $54,748 leaving

03
CompetitionHMDA financed purchases
Purchases by investors5.1%

12 of 234 mortgages

investorother financed
Current listing pressure

What sellers and visible supply are doing

Realtor.com® Economic Research · county inventory 2026-06 · pulled 2026-07-28
Active listings69▲ 29.3% year over year
Median days on market43▼ 2.3% year over year
Listings price-reduced13.1%seller-concession signal
Median listing pricen/a▼ 9.6% year over year

Listing price is an asking price, not a closed sale. Quality-flagged county rows are withheld instead of displayed.

No rent index is published for this county.Zillow’s county rent series does not cover every county, and estimating one from a neighbouring county would be a guess wearing a number’s clothes. Everything above is measured here; for a rent figure, the Canton, OH page covers the wider market.
Same metro

The other counties in Canton, OH

A metro is an average of these. Which side of a county line a property sits on can change the tax bill, the hazard profile and the tenant pool.

CountyPopulationPriceRentYieldHazard
Carroll County26,659$209kn/an/ainland flooding
Stark County373,713$221k$1,1136.0%inland flooding
Bear case

What can break the county thesis

  1. Parcel-level inland-flood exposure, insurance requirements, and repair costs may differ substantially from the county modeled-loss ratio.
  2. Lower MLS asking prices and greater visible supply may challenge an assumed resale value despite the county valuation measures.
  3. Unpublished market rent, vacancy, lease terms, and operating costs could materially change property cash-flow results.
Underwriting questions

Before pricing a property

Can gross yield be calculated from the supplied record?

No. Market rent is not published, and HUD FMR cannot be used as market rent.

Do the Realtor.com figures establish a closed-sale price or prove buyer demand?

No. They are MLS listing-market measures of asking prices and visible supply, not closed-sale evidence or standalone proof of demand.

What does the record show about investor participation?

Non-occupant purchase mortgages are a minority of the recorded purchase mortgages.