How does the same rent look to households and local occupations?
Across directly matched metropolitan areas, how does current asking rent compare with median household income, one all-occupations median wage and the measured housing-cost burden of renter households?
One rent-to-income ratio cannot describe both a household and a worker. This study keeps the two denominators separate, shows how broadly major occupation medians clear the same screen, and anchors them beside HUD's observed renter-burden counts.
- Direct metros
- 378 complete Zillow, ACS, OEWS and CHAS evidence
- Median household share
- 25.1% annual rent / ACS household income
- Median one-worker share
- 37.6% annual rent / OEWS all-occupations wage
- Median measured burden
- 43.1% HUD CHAS moderate plus severe burden
A household median can clear the screen while local occupations do not
Across 378 exact metropolitan matches, the median annualized asking-rent share is 25.1% against ACS median household income but 37.6% against one BLS all-occupations median wage. The difference is not a contradiction: a household may contain multiple earners and non-wage income, while OEWS reports a modeled wage for one worker.
Only 99 metros clear both descriptive screens. Another 215 clear the household-income line while fewer than half of their directly published major occupation medians reach the required-income line. This is why occupation breadth remains visible instead of letting one household median stand in for a labor market.
The HUD result is an observed housing-cost outcome from a different population and period. It checks the story; it is not mathematically caused by either asking-rent ratio.
The included-metro median CHAS burden is 43.1%. Miami, FLrecords the highest aggregate member-county burden at 57.3%, while Santa Cruz, CAhas the widest worker-versus-household ratio gap. The scenario tool can combine one or two direct occupation medians without presenting that arithmetic as an observed household.
The same asking rent against two different income denominators
Right means more pressure against ACS household income; up means more pressure against one all-occupations median wage.
The first 24 rows, with a path to the underlying market
| Rank | Metro | Monthly rent | Required income | Household lens | One-worker lens | Major groups supporting | CHAS burden | Open |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Kahului, HIZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $3,571 | $142,840 | 44.1%$97,109 ACS income | 74.3%$57,640 median wage | 0 / 220.0% | 45.9%18,965 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 2 | New York, NYZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $3,573 | $142,920 | 43.2%$99,155 ACS income | 69.8%$61,430 median wage | 2 / 229.1% | 47.3%3,530,650 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 3 | Miami, FLZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $2,695 | $107,800 | 42.3%$76,527 ACS income | 66.5%$48,640 median wage | 1 / 224.5% | 57.3%914,000 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 4 | Santa Maria, CAZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $3,294 | $131,760 | 40.3%$98,161 ACS income | 76.5%$51,690 median wage | 0 / 220.0% | 51.9%69,865 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 5 | Santa Cruz, CAZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $3,609 | $144,360 | 39.0%$111,093 ACS income | 79.1%$54,730 median wage | 0 / 220.0% | 47.9%38,635 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 6 | Port St. Lucie, FLZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $2,347 | $93,880 | 37.8%$74,514 ACS income | 60.6%$46,490 median wage | 1 / 224.5% | 51.2%42,035 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 7 | Merced, CAZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $2,010 | $80,400 | 36.8%$65,510 ACS income | 51.1%$47,220 median wage | 5 / 2222.7% | 41.3%38,605 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 8 | Los Angeles, CAZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $2,927 | $117,080 | 36.6%$95,958 ACS income | 62.9%$55,850 median wage | 3 / 2213.6% | 52.2%2,274,260 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 9 | El Centro, CAZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $1,756 | $70,240 | 36.5%$57,681 ACS income | 46.7%$45,140 median wage | 9 / 2240.9% | 48.4%19,900 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 10 | Homosassa Springs, FLZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $1,708 | $68,320 | 36.2%$56,546 ACS income | 49.6%$41,360 median wage | 5 / 2222.7% | 46.4%9,890 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 11 | Salinas, CAZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $2,906 | $116,240 | 35.9%$97,230 ACS income | 73.6%$47,380 median wage | 2 / 229.1% | 50.0%62,615 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 12 | Sebastian, FLZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $2,184 | $87,360 | 35.7%$73,491 ACS income | 57.6%$45,480 median wage | 2 / 229.1% | 48.4%13,025 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 13 | Naples, FLZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $2,675 | $107,000 | 35.6%$90,045 ACS income | 67.2%$47,800 median wage | 0 / 210.0% | 55.2%39,405 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 14 | Flagstaff, AZZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $2,123 | $84,920 | 34.9%$72,966 ACS income | 53.6%$47,500 median wage | 4 / 2218.2% | 46.7%21,290 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 15 | San Luis Obispo, CAZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $2,835 | $113,400 | 34.9%$97,446 ACS income | 67.0%$50,770 median wage | 2 / 229.1% | 51.4%41,065 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 16 | Abilene, TXZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $1,935 | $77,400 | 34.5%$67,328 ACS income | 52.4%$44,340 median wage | 3 / 2213.6% | 43.3%24,235 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 17 | Barnstable Town, MAZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $2,725 | $109,000 | 34.3%$95,241 ACS income | 58.0%$56,360 median wage | 1 / 224.5% | 49.4%18,635 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 18 | Urban Honolulu, HIZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $3,038 | $121,520 | 34.3%$106,195 ACS income | 63.7%$57,220 median wage | 0 / 220.0% | 51.7%137,320 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 19 | Hinesville, GAZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $1,749 | $69,960 | 34.0%$61,709 ACS income | 45.0%$46,670 median wage | 7 / 2133.3% | 42.5%14,085 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 20 | Riverside, CAZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $2,539 | $101,560 | 34.0%$89,662 ACS income | 63.0%$48,400 median wage | 2 / 229.1% | 52.6%492,970 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 21 | San Diego, CAZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $2,991 | $119,640 | 33.8%$106,268 ACS income | 61.2%$58,690 median wage | 4 / 2218.2% | 52.6%525,845 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 22 | Lakeland, FLZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $1,848 | $73,920 | 33.6%$65,978 ACS income | 48.1%$46,140 median wage | 6 / 2227.3% | 44.5%79,815 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 23 | Hanford, CAZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $1,983 | $79,320 | 33.5%$70,995 ACS income | 49.1%$48,470 median wage | 7 / 2231.8% | 41.4%19,665 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
| 24 | Boston, MAZillow 2026-06-30 · OEWS 2025-05 | $3,210 | $128,400 | 33.2%$115,863 ACS income | 57.8%$66,620 median wage | 3 / 2213.6% | 44.8%736,130 households · 2018-2022 | Build household |
The visible table is intentionally limited for reading. The CSV contains every row that passes the printed inclusion rule.
Inclusion first, interpretation second.
Include a current metropolitan statistical area only when its exact OMB CBSA has direct Zillow ZORI, ACS median household income, a direct OEWS all-occupations annual median, at least 20 major groups with published annual medians and HUD CHAS coverage for every stored member county. Micropolitan and OEWS nonmetropolitan areas stay out.
Methodology version: v16Method
- Annualized asking rent is current monthly Zillow ZORI multiplied by 12; required gross income divides that annual rent by the descriptive 30 percent screen.
- Household rent share divides annualized rent by ACS median household income. Worker rent share divides the same rent by the direct OEWS all-occupations annual median wage. Neither denominator substitutes for the other.
- Occupation support is the share of directly published major-group annual medians at or above required income. Suppressed medians remain excluded rather than becoming zero or an estimate.
- HUD CHAS moderate and severe burden counts are summed across exact stored member counties, then divided by their published renter-household base. HUD disclosure-rounded counts and the CHAS period remain visible.
Counter-signals
- Median household income can include multiple earners and non-wage income, while OEWS describes one modeled wage-and-salary occupation median.
- A metro can clear a median-income screen while many lower-income renter households remain cost burdened; the CHAS outcome therefore stays independent.
- ZORI, ACS, OEWS and CHAS describe different universes and periods. Their juxtaposition is a named screen, not a synchronized household budget or causal claim.
Limitations
- ZORI is a typical asking-rent index, not the rent paid by the ACS, OEWS or CHAS populations and not a bedroom-specific quote.
- OEWS excludes the self-employed, most agriculture, private households and unpaid family workers, combines six panels over three years and may suppress fields.
- CHAS is a 2018-2022 special tabulation with disclosure-rounded county counts; summing exact member counties does not remove that rounding or reveal household occupations.
- The 30 percent line is a transparent comparison rule, not a universal affordability verdict; taxes, utilities, dependents, debt and household composition remain outside it.
Every input release used by this study
Release and retrieval dates stay visible so a reader can tell whether two measures describe the same moment.